Hey Everybody,
Today I would like to talk about an important issue that comes up here a few times a week: the question of when it is worth repairing and when it is time to send the machine to the recycling center. Many people don’t realize just how quickly laptops lose their value. A laptop you bought for $1,000 just three years ago might be worth as little as $200 today, and you need to consider that when deciding if its time to repair or upgrade.
There are a few things to consider when making a repair versus recycle decision. First, would the client benefit significantly from a new computer? For example, we have a client who does a lot of work in photoshop, and a fast computer is critical for working in photoshop. So when this client had a cracked screen ($250 to replace, including parts) on his $300 value laptop, we all decided it was in his best interests to buy a newer, faster machine.
On the flip side of that, however, many clients do not need a computer that is any faster or better than what they have. For another of our clients who uses her computer solely to e-mail her grandchildren, in that same situation we would probably recommend the screen replacement because there is no additional value in getting her a new laptop.
The second thing you have to consider is: how long is it going to be until something else breaks? For a low quality machine, like a dell D600 or anything built by Gateway, if it’s more than 3 years old it’s almost never worth repairing because it is going to break again soon. If I replace the hard drive in a three year old Gateway (about $200, including parts, labor, and data transfer from the old hard drive) I know that customer will be calling again within 6 months because something else has failed. In that case, it is not worth repairing.
Again, the flip side is that for a high quality laptop, like an IBM thinkpad or an HP business laptop, I know they are likely to last much longer. In that case I am much more likely to recommend replacing the one bad part because I have a much higher confidence that the rest of the machine has serious lifespan left in it.
Finally, the last thing to consider is simply the raw cost. Many of our clients are on a tight budget and do not have the kind of money necessary to buy a new laptop. Even a cheap new laptop will run about $500, and a good, high quality one that will last for 4-5 years costs $1,000. So, if the money simply isn’t there, even if it might not make sense otherwise, duct-taping a machine together so it keeps going can be the priority.
As an example, we recently had a client who needed a new laptop screen. The computer was old and pretty badly beat up, worth maybe $150, but the client simply did not have the money to buy a new laptop. For him, spending $200 to replace the screen was the best decision.
I would like to make one last point, by the way, for those who might be inclined to say, “why not just take that $200 and buy a used laptop?” The answer is simple: laptop lifespan depends a great deal on the owner. If you buy a used laptop, you have no way of knowing how it is has been treated, what has been done inside of it, or what kind of lifespan it has left. Many a sad client has bought a used laptop and then had it last for only a month or two before dying. I always think that it’s better to work with a machine you know than one you don’t.
Okay, so those are my thoughts on when to repair or not repair your machine. Thanks for reading!
-Zac